CNN
By Eric Levenson, Gabe Cohen and Celina Tebor, CNN
Louisville police released two videos Thursday showing some of the arrest of star golfer Scottie Scheffler last week and announced the detective who arrested him was disciplined for not turning on his body-worn camera at the time.
One video from a fixed pole camera positioned across the street shows portions of the interaction between Scheffler and police. In the video, a vehicle turns left and an officer wearing reflective gear runs toward the vehicle, which then stops. Police then take the driver out of the car and a group of three people walk across the street.
A second video from a police vehicle’s dashcam shows two officers walking with a handcuffed Scheffler.
The videos were released a week after Scheffler was arrested, charged with felony assault, released from jail and then made his tee time in a whirlwind few hours at the PGA Championship, one of golf’s four major tournaments.
The world no. 1 golfer was attempting to drive to the Valhalla Golf Club in Louisville for the second round of the tournament at about 6 a.m. when he came to the scene of a fatal crash. He allegedly injured a police officer who was directing traffic and was arrested, according to police.
Scheffler, 27, a new father with a sterling reputation, was charged with felony second-degree assault on a police officer, along with lesser charges of third-degree criminal mischief, reckless driving and disregarding signals from officers directing traffic, according to Jefferson County court records.
After taking a mug shot and warming up in a jail cell, he was released and made it to his tee time at the golf club. He then shot 5-under that day on his way to finishing the tournament in a tie for 8th place.
Scheffler described the incident as a “big misunderstanding” during a “chaotic situation.”
After the news conference Thursday, Scheffler’s attorney, Steve Romines, reiterated the golfer still plans to plead not guilty to the charges.
“It won’t impact my case at all. Our position is the same as it was last Friday: Scottie Scheffler didn’t do anything wrong. We’re not interested in settling the case. We will either try it or it’ll be dismissed. It’s very simple,” he said. “All the evidence that continues to come out just continues to support what Scottie said all along, this was a chaotic situation and a miscommunication and he didn’t do anything wrong.”
High-ranking police officials in Louisville have privately voiced concerns a felony charge against Scheffler is excessive, a source familiar with the discussions told CNN.
Prosecutors said Thursday they continue to investigate the case.
“The Jefferson County Attorney’s office has continued to receive evidence and has yet to conduct final interviews with investigators regarding the charges filed by LMPD against Mr. Scheffler,” said Josh Abner, a spokesman for the office. “As we have stated previously, no decisions have been made and our review continues.”
Scheffler, meanwhile, teed off for his first round at the Charles Schwab Challenge in Fort Worth, Texas, on Thursday afternoon.
Police discipline detective for not activating body-worn camera
At a news conference Thursday, Louisville’s mayor and police chief announced an internal investigation of the case led to discipline for the arresting officer, Detective Bryan Gillis.
“Detective Gillis should have turned on his body-worn camera, but did not,” Police Chief Jacquelyn Gwinn-Villaroel said. “His failure to do so is a violation of the LMPD policy on uniforms and equipment, subject category body-worn camera.”
The police chief said Gillis did not have his body-worn camera “operationally ready” as required. The detective has received “corrective action,” said the chief, who did not provide specifics about the discipline at the news conference.
A Louisville police memo the department subsequently released Thursday said the detective “was counseled by a member of his command on May 22, 2024, and a performance observation was completed.”
The memo was among documents released related to the detective’s failure to activate his body-worn camera. In one, Gillis explained he “never powered up” the camera and described his own version of what happened.
“While directing traffic in front of Gate 1 the PGA personnel stopped a bus from entering Gate 1,” he wrote. “I observed a vehicle traveling in the opposing lanes coming at me. I stopped the driver and advised him he could not proceed because of the bus. He demanded to be let in, and proceeded forward against my directions. I was dragged/knocked down by the driver. I then proceeded to arrest the driver.”
Neither Mayor Craig Greenberg nor the police chief took questions from the media at Thursday’s news conference.
“Activating body-worn cameras is critically important for our police department to have evidence, to maintain community trust, to be transparent,” Greenberg said.
Documents obtained by CNN show Gillis has a history of both reprimands and suspensions within the police department.
Gillis, who began his service in 2007, has received six reprimands throughout his time with Louisville police, a disciplinary history report shows. He has also been suspended on five separate occasions. None of Gillis’ prior suspensions involved failing to turn on his body-worn camera.
Records also show Gillis has received several commendations during his career, including back-to-back Meritorious Unit Citations in 2019.
The detective’s longest suspension at five days stems from a 2012 incident in which Gillis allegedly drove an “intoxicated civilian” in his police vehicle while doing “donuts” in a business parking lot while his emergency lights were illuminated, according to a 2013 LMPD document.
More recently, in 2021, Gillis received a written reprimand for pursuing “a vehicle that did not commit a violent felony or wanted on a warrant,” documents show. Additionally, Gillis did not tell dispatchers he was engaging in a vehicle pursuit at the time, according to LMPD documents.
The year prior, in 2012, he faced a four-day suspension for failing to appear in court on multiple occasions between 2010 and 2011. Documents show Gillis was also found “at fault” for three crashes, for which he received reprimands and mandatory driver’s training.
CNN has reached out to the Louisville Police Department for comment and was told “as this matter is before the courts, commenting further on the participants (defendants, witnesses, and victims alike) is not appropriate for us to do.”
Gillis did not immediately respond to CNN’s request for comment Friday. CNN has also reached out to the River City Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 614, the union representing LMPD detectives, for comment on Gillis’ past conduct.
What we know about the arrest
According to a Louisville Metro Police report, Scheffler was trying to drive into the golf course when he was stopped by an officer wearing a full police uniform and a yellow reflective rain jacket. The officer, identified as Gillis, stopped Scheffler and “attempted to give instructions,” the report states.
“Subject refused to comply and accelerated forward, dragging Detective Gillis to the ground,” according to the report.
The detective suffered pain, swelling and abrasions to his left wrist and knee and was taken to the hospital for further treatment, the report states. His uniform pants, valued at about $80, “were damaged beyond repair,” the report adds.
Romines, Scheffler’s attorney, said the golfer was headed to the course early to prepare to play.
“Due to the combination of event traffic and a traffic fatality in the area, it was a very chaotic situation. He was proceeding as directed by another traffic officer and driving a marked player’s vehicle with credentials visible,” Romines said in a statement. “In the confusion, Scottie is alleged to have disregarded a different officer’s traffic signals resulting in these charges.”
Multiple eyewitnesses have said Scheffler “did not do anything wrong” but drove as directed, according to Romines.
“He stopped immediately upon being directed to and never at any point assaulted any officer with his vehicle,” the statement reads.
ESPN’s Jeff Darlington witnessed the encounter and filmed part of it. When Scheffler arrived in a marked player courtesy vehicle, he tried to drive around the crash scene on a median, according to ESPN. Darlington wrote on social media Scheffler “continued to drive about 10 to 20 yards toward the entrance” before stopping.
“The police officer attempted to attach himself to Scheffler’s car, and Scheffler then stopped his vehicle at the entrance to Valhalla,” Darlington wrote on X. “The police officer then began to scream at Scheffler to get out of the car. When Scheffler exited the vehicle, the officer shoved Scheffler against the car and immediately placed him in handcuffs.”
Police escorted a handcuffed Scheffler into a police vehicle, Darlington’s video shows.
“Right now he’s going to jail,” an officer at the scene says in the video.
Scheffler’s arraignment was originally scheduled for Tuesday but was delayed to June due to his attorney’s scheduling issue.
This story has been updated with additional information.
The-CNN-Wire
™ & © 2024 Cable News Network, Inc., a Warner Bros. Discovery Company. All rights reserved.
CNN’s Ray Sanchez and Artemis Moshtaghian contributed to this report.
