While the ’90s gave us countless celebrity outfits made infamous by their boldness and creativity—Liz Hurley in the Versace safety pin dress, Naomi Campbell’s thigh-high cobalt blue socks—not all of them are easy to replicate for everyday wear. But if you dig through the archives, you’ll discover plenty of understated A-lister looks that don’t just shine quietly in the context of the decade, but also fit into 2024’s fashion landscape.

With a new, warmer season to dress for, I’ve looked to five ’90s trendsetters for guidance. The era’s aesthetic continues to inspire modern collections, and it’s easy to see why: amidst the grunge accessories and daring runway looks, the style was defined by simple silhouettes and elevated basics.